Protective Service · SOC 33-1012
First-Line Supervisors of Police and Detectives
Directly supervise and coordinate activities of members of police force.
Will AI replace this job?
The data cannot say, and anyone who gives you a percentage for “replaced” is guessing. What it does show is a gap between three things, for the 20 tasks O*NET lists for this occupation:
Could an LLM do it?
10%–15%
of tasks: an LLM alone could do the task or cut its time by half. Human raters say 15%, GPT-4 says 10%.
Counting tasks that need extra software around the model: 40%–55%.
Is it happening?
0 of 20 tasks
show measurable use in Claude conversations (Anthropic Economic Index). Anthropic’s occupation score, which counts only tasks that were also rated feasible, is 0%. Observed is a subset of “could” by construction.
Claude only, mostly US users, sampled periods in 2025. Not all AI use, and not employment.
What is left?
6 of 20 tasks
were rated “no LLM speed-up” by every rater (so, by Anthropic’s method, they cannot show up as observed use either). That is the part of the job these studies see no sign of AI touching.
It does not mean those tasks are safe. It means these methods found nothing there.
Task by task
Sorted with the tasks seen in use first. The three coloured squares are the three raters, in this order: human raters, GPT-4, GPT-4 with an alternative rubric. “Usage score” is Anthropic’s published task_penetration value; 0 means none seen.
| Task (O*NET 31.0) | Could an LLM? | Claude usage score |
|---|---|---|
| Prepare work schedules and assign duties to subordinates. | all raters | none seen |
| Maintain logs, prepare reports, and direct the preparation, handling, and maintenance of departmental records. | all raters | none seen |
| Inform personnel of changes in regulations and policies, implications of new or amended laws, and new techniques of police work. | all raters | none seen |
| Review contents of written orders to ensure adherence to legal requirements. | all raters | none seen |
| Develop, implement, and revise departmental policies and procedures. (supplemental) | all raters | none seen |
| Prepare news releases and respond to police correspondence. (supplemental) | all raters | none seen |
| Prepare budgets and manage expenditures of department funds. (supplemental) | all raters | none seen |
| Supervise and coordinate the investigation of criminal cases, offering guidance and expertise to investigators, and ensuring that procedures are conducted in accordance with laws and regulations. | 2 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Monitor and evaluate the job performance of subordinates, and authorize promotions and transfers. | 2 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Direct collection, preparation, and handling of evidence and personal property of prisoners. | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Investigate and resolve personnel problems within organization and charges of misconduct against staff. | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Train staff in proper police work procedures. | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Meet with civic, educational, and community groups to develop community programs and events, and to discuss law enforcement subjects. | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Requisition and issue equipment and supplies. | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Explain police operations to subordinates to assist them in performing their job duties. | no rater | none seen |
| Discipline staff for violation of department rules and regulations. | no rater | none seen |
| Conduct raids and order detention of witnesses and suspects for questioning. | no rater | none seen |
| Cooperate with court personnel and officials from other law enforcement agencies and testify in court, as necessary. | no rater | none seen |
| Inspect facilities, supplies, vehicles, and equipment to ensure conformance to standards. | no rater | none seen |
| Direct release or transfer of prisoners. | no rater | none seen |
Try it with your own task list
Sources: task list from O*NET® Database (U.S. Department of Labor, CC BY 4.0; modified by noworkleft.com); “could” labels from Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs (OpenAI/University of Pennsylvania, MIT licence, labels from early-2023 models); “seen in use” from the Anthropic Economic Index (Claude usage only, CC BY). Dates, versions and limits.
Other jobs in Protective Service
- Police and Sheriff's Patrol Officers (12% observed)
- Protective Service Workers, All Other (6% observed)
- Detectives and Criminal Investigators (4% observed)
- First-Line Supervisors of Correctional Officers (3% observed)
- First-Line Supervisors of Firefighting and Prevention Workers (0% observed)
- Firefighters (0% observed)
- Fire Inspectors and Investigators (0% observed)
- Forest Fire Inspectors and Prevention Specialists (0% observed)
Data built 2026-11-06. O*NET 31.0. Task match rates: 99.4% with the OpenAI/Penn labels, 99.2% with Anthropic usage.