Protective Service · SOC 33-3021
Detectives and Criminal Investigators
Conduct investigations related to suspected violations of federal, state, or local laws to prevent or solve crimes.
Will AI replace this job?
The data cannot say, and anyone who gives you a percentage for “replaced” is guessing. What it does show is a gap between three things, for the 67 tasks O*NET lists for this occupation:
Could an LLM do it?
8%–9%
of tasks: an LLM alone could do the task or cut its time by half. Human raters say 8%, GPT-4 says 9%.
Counting tasks that need extra software around the model: 54%–68%.
Is it happening?
3 of 67 tasks
show measurable use in Claude conversations (Anthropic Economic Index). Anthropic’s occupation score, which counts only tasks that were also rated feasible, is 4%. Observed is a subset of “could” by construction.
Claude only, mostly US users, sampled periods in 2025. Not all AI use, and not employment.
What is left?
14 of 67 tasks
were rated “no LLM speed-up” by every rater (so, by Anthropic’s method, they cannot show up as observed use either). That is the part of the job these studies see no sign of AI touching.
It does not mean those tasks are safe. It means these methods found nothing there.
Task by task
Sorted with the tasks seen in use first. The three coloured squares are the three raters, in this order: human raters, GPT-4, GPT-4 with an alternative rubric. “Usage score” is Anthropic’s published task_penetration value; 0 means none seen.
| Task (O*NET 31.0) | Could an LLM? | Claude usage score |
|---|---|---|
| Prepare reports that detail investigation findings. | all raters | 0.72 |
| Design, use, or maintain databases and software applications, such as geographic information systems (GIS) mapping and artificial intelligence tools. | all raters | 0.90 |
| Gather intelligence information by field observation, confidential information sources, or public records. | 2 of 3 raters | 1.00 |
| Obtain facts or statements from complainants, witnesses, and accused persons and record interviews, using recording device. | all raters | none seen |
| Record progress of investigation, maintain informational files on suspects, and submit reports to commanding officer or magistrate to authorize warrants. | all raters | none seen |
| Analyze completed police reports to determine what additional information and investigative work is needed. | all raters | none seen |
| Determine scope, timing, and direction of investigations. | all raters | none seen |
| Examine records and governmental agency files to find identifying data about suspects. | all raters | none seen |
| Examine records to locate links in chains of evidence or information. | all raters | none seen |
| Prepare charges or responses to charges, or information for court cases, according to formalized procedures. | all raters | none seen |
| Provide information to lab personnel concerning the source of an item of evidence and tests to be performed. | all raters | none seen |
| Notify, or request notification of, medical examiner or district attorney representative. | all raters | none seen |
| Photograph crime or accident scenes for evidence records. | all raters | none seen |
| Maintain records of evidence and write and review reports. | all raters | none seen |
| Process film and prints from crime or accident scenes. | all raters | none seen |
| Create sketches and diagrams, by hand or computer software, to depict crime scenes. | all raters | none seen |
| Validate known intelligence with data from other sources. | all raters | none seen |
| Gather, analyze, correlate, or evaluate information from a variety of resources, such as law enforcement databases. | all raters | none seen |
| Evaluate records of communications, such as telephone calls, to plot activity and determine the size and location of criminal groups and members. | all raters | none seen |
| Analyze intelligence data to identify patterns and trends in criminal activity. | all raters | none seen |
| Prepare comprehensive written reports, presentations, maps, or charts, based on research, collection, and analysis of intelligence data. | all raters | none seen |
| Establish criminal profiles to aid in connecting criminal organizations with their members. | all raters | none seen |
| Predict future gang, organized crime, or terrorist activity, using analyses of intelligence data. | all raters | none seen |
| Conduct presentations of analytic findings. | all raters | none seen |
| Develop defense plans or tactics, using intelligence and other information. (supplemental) | all raters | none seen |
| Prepare plans to intercept foreign communications transmissions. (supplemental) | all raters | none seen |
| Gather and evaluate information, using tools such as aerial photographs, radar equipment, or sensitive radio equipment. (supplemental) | all raters | none seen |
| Obtain and verify evidence by interviewing and observing suspects and witnesses or by analyzing records. | 2 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Note, mark, and photograph location of objects found, such as footprints, tire tracks, bullets and bloodstains, and take measurements of the scene. | 2 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Identify case issues and evidence needed, based on analysis of charges, complaints, or allegations of law violations. | 2 of 3 raters | none seen |
Show the other 37 tasks
| Maintain surveillance of establishments to obtain identifying information on suspects. | 2 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Submit evidence to supervisors, crime labs, or court officials for legal proceedings. | 2 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Serve as technical advisor and coordinate with other law enforcement workers or legal personnel to exchange information on crime scene collection activities. | 2 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Coordinate or conduct instructional classes or in-services, such as citizen police academy classes and crime scene training for other officers. | 2 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Collaborate with representatives from other government and intelligence organizations to share information or coordinate intelligence activities. | 2 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Link or chart suspects to criminal organizations or events to determine activities and interrelationships. | 2 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Study activities relating to narcotics, money laundering, gangs, auto theft rings, terrorism, or other national security threats. | 2 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Study the assets of criminal suspects to determine the flow of money from or to targeted groups. | 2 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Study communication code languages or foreign languages to translate intelligence. (supplemental) | 2 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Preserve, process, and analyze items of evidence obtained from crime scenes and suspects, placing them in proper containers and destroying evidence no longer needed. | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Organize scene search, assigning specific tasks and areas of search to individual officers and obtaining adequate lighting as necessary. | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Obtain summary of incident from officer in charge at crime scene, taking care to avoid disturbing evidence. | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Collaborate with other offices and agencies to exchange information and coordinate activities. | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Summon medical help for injured individuals and alert medical personnel to take statements from them. | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Notify command of situation and request assistance. | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Perform undercover assignments and maintain surveillance, including monitoring authorized wiretaps. | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Look for trace evidence, such as fingerprints, hairs, fibers, or shoe impressions, using alternative light sources when necessary. | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Analyze and process evidence at crime scenes, during autopsies, or in the laboratory, wearing protective equipment and using powders and chemicals. | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Package, store and retrieve evidence. | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Identify, compare, classify, and file fingerprints, using systems such as Automated Fingerprint Identification System (AFIS) or the Henry Classification System. (supplemental) | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Interview survivors, witnesses, suspects, and other law enforcement personnel. (supplemental) | 1 of 3 raters | n/a |
| Interview, interrogate, or interact with witnesses or crime suspects to collect human intelligence. (supplemental) | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Operate cameras, radios, or other surveillance equipment to intercept communications or document activities. (supplemental) | 1 of 3 raters | none seen |
| Secure deceased body and obtain evidence from it, preventing bystanders from tampering with it prior to medical examiner's arrival. | no rater | none seen |
| Search for and collect evidence, such as fingerprints, using investigative equipment. | no rater | none seen |
| Prepare and serve search and arrest warrants. | no rater | none seen |
| Testify before grand juries concerning criminal activity investigations. | no rater | none seen |
| Secure persons at scene, keeping witnesses from conversing or leaving the scene before investigators arrive. | no rater | none seen |
| Participate or assist in raids and arrests. | no rater | none seen |
| Question individuals or observe persons and establishments to confirm information given to patrol officers. | no rater | none seen |
| Check victims for signs of life, such as breathing and pulse. | no rater | none seen |
| Block or rope off scene and check perimeter to ensure that entire scene is secured. | no rater | none seen |
| Testify in court and present evidence. | no rater | none seen |
| Dust selected areas of crime scene and lift latent fingerprints, adhering to proper preservation procedures. | no rater | none seen |
| Take fingerprints. | not rated | n/a |
| Perform emergency work during off-hours. | no rater | none seen |
| Identify gaps in information. | not rated | n/a |
Try it with your own task list
Sources: task list from O*NET® Database (U.S. Department of Labor, CC BY 4.0; modified by noworkleft.com); “could” labels from Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs (OpenAI/University of Pennsylvania, MIT licence, labels from early-2023 models); “seen in use” from the Anthropic Economic Index (Claude usage only, CC BY). Dates, versions and limits.
Other jobs in Protective Service
- Police and Sheriff's Patrol Officers (12% observed)
- Protective Service Workers, All Other (6% observed)
- First-Line Supervisors of Correctional Officers (3% observed)
- First-Line Supervisors of Police and Detectives (0% observed)
- First-Line Supervisors of Firefighting and Prevention Workers (0% observed)
- Firefighters (0% observed)
- Fire Inspectors and Investigators (0% observed)
- Forest Fire Inspectors and Prevention Specialists (0% observed)
Data built 2026-11-06. O*NET 31.0. Task match rates: 99.4% with the OpenAI/Penn labels, 99.2% with Anthropic usage.